Puritan Advice for Christian Controversy on Social Media

You may be sure that most quarrels among Christians on social media tend to the ruin of the Church, the hindrance of the gospel, and the injury of the common interest of Christianity. You know ungodly divisions are greatly condemned in the scriptures, and that they are usually the result of pride, uncharitableness, and temper, and that the Devil is best pleased with it because he gains the most by it.

If arguments cause any divisions, be sure to look first to the interest of common truth and good and to the exercise of love: and do not become passionate contenders for any party in the division or censure those to do not enter the fight, but join instead with the moderate and the peacemakers than with the contenders and dividers.

I understand that those who want to draw you into a combative fervor will tell you that their cause is the cause of God and that you will betray him if you are not zealous in it. They will tell you that your sinfulness makes you selfishly desire moderation and peace. They will also condemn you by saying you are hypocrites, that you are lukewarm, and that you agree with error. And they are right if it is indeed the cause of God, but upon great experience, I must tell you that of the zealous contenders online that claim the cause of God and truth, very few know what they are talking about.

Some of them claim the cause of God when their cause is the spoiled spawn of a proud and ignorant mind. Some are impassioned before they have even had time to give it any serious thought. Others are led astray by some person or tribe that fascinates their minds. Many are blinded by their carnal interests, and many of them, in mere pride, think highly of an opinion because they believe they know more than ordinary men do. Finally, many of them are simply looking for likes and retweets, and the general atmosphere of social media will almost certainly corrupt the controversy further.

As far as my judgment has been able to reach, the people that have stood for restraint have been the most sensible and have had the best understanding of the controversies under debate among good Christians. Those that castigate them as lukewarm or corrupted have been people that have had the least judgment and are usually full of proud and foul mistakes in the points in question.

In all this, I do not deny that every truth of God is to be highly valued and that those who plead for neutrality, when the essential doctrines of the faith are being disputed, are false-hearted hypocrites. However, some truths must be silenced for a time (though not denied) when contending for them is untimely and tends to the injury of the Church. Especially when the platform is not conducive to maintaining a healthy dispute. Take heed of what you do online when God’s honor, men’s souls, and the Church’s peace are at stake.

-Richard Baxter on Christian Controversy (Rewritten for today’s reader and applied to social media)

Leave a comment